Vegetarian · American cuisine

Peanut Butter Sandwich

sandwichpeanut butterquicksnack
6 ingredients Cuisine: American Page updated October 2026

This peanut butter sandwich gets its character from a filling that is blended before it ever touches the bread. Peanut butter, honey and butter are mixed into a rich, sweet spread, then set against jam on buttered toast. The warm crunch of the toast and the cold milk on the side make a five minute lunch that feels more considered than the usual spread-and-fold.

Instructions

Toast the two slices of bread, then spread soft butter over them while they are still warm.

In a small bowl, mix together peanut butter, honey and some more butter until you have a smooth, spreadable paste. Spread it over one slice of the toast.

Spread preserves over the second slice. Press the two slices together with the fillings facing in.

Cut the sandwich in half and serve it right away with a glass of very cold milk. If the peanut butter mixture is too runny to handle, skip the extra butter and spread a thin layer of honey on both slices instead.

Plant-Based Sprout Living

Real ingredients, clean nutrition.

Plant-based protein, superfoods, and pantry staples made from whole ingredients. Recipes on their blog too.

Browse Sprout Living →

Affiliate link · PicksByRecipe may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Round out the meal

What to serve with it

Similar

More vegetarian

Get new posts in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.